When a legal relationship involves several countries, two questions must be distinguished: which court has jurisdiction to decide the dispute, and which law must that court apply?
In relationships between French and Italian companies, these issues arise particularly during the performance or termination of an international contract.
ALTEREGAL advises companies on conflicts of laws and jurisdiction between France and Italy, taking into account French law, Italian law and the applicable European legal framework.
These matters must be considered in light of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (“Brussels I bis”), which governs jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments—now without an exequatur procedure between EU Member States—and Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (“Rome I”), which governs the law applicable to contractual obligations, including the principle of party autonomy.
In relationships between French and Italian companies, these issues arise particularly during the performance or termination of an international contract.
ALTEREGAL advises companies on conflicts of laws and jurisdiction between France and Italy, taking into account French law, Italian law and the applicable European legal framework.
These matters must be considered in light of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (“Brussels I bis”), which governs jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments—now without an exequatur procedure between EU Member States—and Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (“Rome I”), which governs the law applicable to contractual obligations, including the principle of party autonomy.
Which court has jurisdiction between France and Italy?
The fact that one party is French and the other Italian is not, in itself, sufficient to determine which court should hear a dispute.
The contractual clauses, nature of the obligation, circumstances of its performance and rules governing international jurisdiction must be analysed.
A choice-of-court clause may play a decisive role if it has been validly agreed and applies to the dispute in question.
The contractual clauses, nature of the obligation, circumstances of its performance and rules governing international jurisdiction must be analysed.
A choice-of-court clause may play a decisive role if it has been validly agreed and applies to the dispute in question.
Which law applies to a French-Italian contract?
The court with jurisdiction does not necessarily apply the law of its own country to the substance of the dispute.
The law applicable to a contract between France and Italy must therefore be analysed separately.
The parties’ choice of law in the contract may be central, subject to the rules applicable to the particular circumstances.
These issues should ideally be addressed when the contract is drafted.
The law applicable to a contract between France and Italy must therefore be analysed separately.
The parties’ choice of law in the contract may be central, subject to the rules applicable to the particular circumstances.
These issues should ideally be addressed when the contract is drafted.
Why address these issues before a dispute arises?
International jurisdiction and the applicable law may directly affect the strategy, the conduct of proceedings and the assessment of the parties’ rights.
Where a dispute already exists, examining these issues is a preliminary step before bringing a claim.
The assessment must also take into account whether the future decision can be recognised and enforced in the country where the debtor or its assets are located.
ALTEREGAL therefore advises French and Italian companies on developing a coherent strategy for international jurisdiction, applicable law and cross-border enforcement.
Contact ALTEREGAL to discuss a conflict of laws or jurisdiction between France and Italy.Where a dispute already exists, examining these issues is a preliminary step before bringing a claim.
The assessment must also take into account whether the future decision can be recognised and enforced in the country where the debtor or its assets are located.
ALTEREGAL therefore advises French and Italian companies on developing a coherent strategy for international jurisdiction, applicable law and cross-border enforcement.